Data Dashboards Are Making Communicators Dumber

-

Not long ago, we walked into a pitch with a regional brand team. They proudly showed us their “cutting-edge” PR dashboard: a glossy interface packed with charts, graphs, and numbers that spun and updated in real time.

It looked impressive. But five minutes in, we asked a simple question:
“So, what decisions are you making based on this data?”

Silence.

The truth is most dashboards are beautiful distractions. They count clicks, mentions, impressions, and sentiment scores; but rarely tie those metrics back to business outcomes. Worse, they give leaders a false sense of control: as if more colourful charts somehow equal smarter strategy.

In practice, we’ve seen teams paralysed by dashboards. They obsess over vanity spikes (“Look! Engagement’s up 35% this week!”) but can’t explain whether customer trust actually improved, whether stakeholders feel reassured, or whether sales conversations got easier. That gap -- between what’s tracked and what actually matters -- is where communicators lose credibility.

Here’s what we’ve learned from fixing this gap for clients across Asia-Pacific:

  • Vanity metrics ≠ strategy. A million impressions don’t matter if no one’s behaviour changed.

  • Dashboards can distort focus. Teams chase what looks good on a graph instead of addressing real reputational risks.

  • Leaders want clarity, not noise. The best dashboards aren’t dashboards at all; they’re decision-making models that link comms activity to tangible outcomes.

Case in point: one client was drowning in a “sea of green” (all their metrics looked positive). Yet their stakeholder surveys told another story: declining trust, increasing skepticism, and stalled partnerships. Once we re-engineered their measurement model, the picture changed, and so did their decisions.

That’s the difference between dashboards that flatter, and dashboards that matter.

At Orchan, we don’t worship dashboards. We design measurement models that cut through the noise, show what really drives reputation, and give leaders the confidence to act on data that actually means something.

Because the goal isn’t prettier dashboards. It’s smarter decisions.

Quick FAQ: Dashboards vs. Decision-Making

Q: Are dashboards useless?
Not at all -- they’re tools. But without context, they risk becoming expensive vanity mirrors.

Q: What should communicators measure instead of impressions?
Trust, sentiment shifts, behaviour change, stakeholder alignment -- metrics that connect to real-world outcomes.

Q: How do you turn data into decisions?
By building models that answer “so what?” at every level of reporting. If a chart doesn’t inform action, it’s dead weight.

“Vanity metrics don’t build trust. Behaviour change does.”

Ready to cut through vanity metrics?
Let’s talk: changenow@orchan.asia | +603-7972 6377

Comments

Post a Comment

We value clear, constructive input. Spam and off-topic comments won’t be published -- but sharp perspectives always are.

Popular posts from this blog

How to Choose the Best PR Agency in Malaysia: A Practical Guide for Brands

-
Image
When you search “best PR agency in Malaysia,” you’ll find endless lists, awards, and glossy websites. Every agency claims to be the most creative, the most connected, or the most “integrated.” But the truth is: the best PR agency for your brand depends on more than hype or a clever tagline. At its core, public relations is about trust, reputation, and relationships. Choosing the right partner can make the difference between a campaign that fades after a press release, and one that builds lasting credibility. So, how do you separate the buzz from the substance? 1. Look Beyond the Hype A slick website or big client logos don’t tell the full story. Ask: What measurable impact did the agency deliver for those clients? Are there long-term relationships, or just one-off projects? Do they have sector-specific experience (e.g., fintech, lifestyle, NGOs) that matches your needs? The best PR partners don’t just chase headlines. They help you build brand equity over time. 2. Test Their Crisis Re...
Read more

Are You a Dirty Consultant? She Was! (Part 1)

-
Image
At Orchan, we’ve seen consulting at its best - and at its glossiest. Dirty Consultant is our no-nonsense series calling out the theatre, the buzzwords, and the shiny distractions that get in the way of real change. Because true consulting isn’t about polished decks or clever algorithms; it’s about rolling up sleeves, getting into the grit, and facing the messy human reality head-on. Are you a dirty consultant? She was. Back then, she didn’t sit behind a shiny desk. She pulled night shifts. She rode shotgun with truckers. She sweated it out in the warehouse. She asked the tough questions: to managers in ties, and to workers in boots. She refused to give advice until she knew what the advice meant for the people who had to live with it. That was consulting. Now? Consultants stroll in polished and perfect. Designer suits. Fresh slides. Laptops glowing like neon signs. They sell “platforms” and “solutions” and “engagement dashboards.” But they won’t get their hands di...
Read more

Stop Trying to Be Everyone’s Favourite: Why Bold Branding in Southeast Asia Wins by Standing Apart

-
Image
We recently came across a sharp piece from ET BrandEquity titled “Stop Trying to Be Liked: Why Great Brand Strategy Repels More Than It Attracts.” It struck a chord with us at Orchan, because we’ve seen the same truth play out across Southeast Asia: the strongest brands don’t aim to please everyone. They stand for something, and by doing so, they inevitably turn some people away. But here’s the catch; in our region’s complex cultural mix, bold branding can be both a strength and a risk. Done well, it creates loyalty and cultural relevance. Done poorly, it sparks backlash or fades into noise. (Libresse V-Kebaya Campaign) Malaysian Brands That Took a Stand Libresse’s V-Kebaya campaign (2021) used vulva-inspired kebaya designs to challenge taboos around women’s bodies. For some, it was empowering; for others, offensive. The backlash eventually saw it pulled, but it trended for weeks, boosted sales, and even won awards. It showed how boldness, rooted in local culture, can make a brand impo...
Read more